Saturday, 30 May 2020

Two Resin Rarities


Two more rare resin kits from the collection of Kevin Bade which he has kindly shared here. Both are to 1/72 scale. Kevin believes they were made by a Japanese hobby shop and he bought them via a friend with contacts in Japan. The only English is 'Mechadoll' on the cardboard backing of the Ki-94-II kit (and recorded as such at Scalemates), but not sure if that is the actual trade name. There are no decals but the castings are excellent and Kevin reckons them to be as good or better than anything since.


Crisp moulding and internal details together with comprehensive instructions distinguish the Tachikawa Ki-94-II kit shown above, released during the 1990s. RS Models issued a series of limited run injection molded plastic kits of this type from 2006 with the most recent re-release featuring decals for three spurious  operational schemes last year .     


The Mitsubishi Ki-83 kit appears to be an equally impressive product, the colour photos revealing a good looking model of a very attractive twin-engined fighter design. MPM released an injection molded plastic limited-run kit of the Ki-83 in 2000 which was re-released in a 'High-tech' version by Special Hobby in 2008.  

With special thanks to Kevin for providing these images and details of the kits. 

Image credit: All © 2020 Kevin Bade.



Thursday, 28 May 2020

Friendship Scale Models 1/72 Ki-59


Following previous retrospectives in November and December 2019 about the late Horatio Hernández of Mexico and his pioneering line of Friendship Scale Models resin and vacform Japanese aircraft kits, Kevin Bade has very kindly shared these images of an unbuilt 1/72 Kokusai Ki-59 kit from his own collection. This was Horatio's first release as Kit FSM-001.


Kevin purchased this kit direct from Horatio in 1994 together with the Tachikawa Ki-77 and Kawasaki Ki-78 kits. He found that all if them were very well done with good decals, instructions and historical notes, presenting thorough, high quality products with vacuform parts as good as any he had ever seen and good resin casting too.    


The quality and completeness of the kit as a first release is self evident from Kevin's photos, with the main components shown on two vacform sheets, together with separately bagged resin moulded detail parts and vacform transparencies. The decal sheet looks excellent and the instructions, exploded view, plans and especially historical notes are of an exceptional standard.  


With very special thanks to Kevin for providing these views of a very rare kit in its pristine and as bought' condition. 

Image credit: Heading photo © 2019 Guillermo; Kit photos © 2020 Kevin Bade

Saturday, 16 May 2020

Mark Smith's 1/48 Mitsubishi A5M4 'Claude'


Aviation of Japan's Texas correspondent Mark Smith has very kindly shared these images and a very useful build report of his stunning Fine Molds 1/48 scale Mitsubishi A5M4 'Claude' - Type 96 Carrier Fighter (Kyu-roku Shiki Kanjoh Sentoh-ki -九六式艦上戦闘機), popularly referred to as 'Kyu-roku Kansen' (九六艦戦). This kind of detailed 'build chat' is rare these days but used to be a staple of the older modelling magazines and it is refreshing to be able to enjoy again.  Over to Mark then:-

"After many years without a new tool A5M4 Claude kit in 1/48 and within the space of a few months in 2017 modelers had a choice between excellent examples from Fine Molds (FM) and a new company, Wingsy.  It was great news on all fronts: each has its advantages, and both build into convincing replicas. 


"The Wingsy and FM kits both have excellent detail where it matters most: the cockpit and that big radial Kotobuki engine.  With its inclusion of photoetched details, Wingsy’s cockpit is better and more accurate, if a little more trouble; Wingsy’s surface detail was a revelation, superior to FM’s effort as well, and its canopy has less optical distortion in that topmost pane with all the corners.  My goal when I selected between them, however, was the simplicity of the build.  For that reason I chose Fine Molds because after dry-fitting the engine and cowl assemblies of both kits, FM appeared to have a clear edge in this area for design and fit.  


"One way the FM kit is different from ‘old school’ molds is in its limited mating surfaces for several assemblies; in playing with their Karigane / Ki-15 Babs kits, released not long afterward, the same approach is apparent.  It’s a trade-off that comes from the very fine tolerances necessary to mold parts to ‘scale thinness’ - so that complex assemblies like engines and cockpits, and the spatial arrangement of their elements, can be represented more faithfully.  Ironically, part of the challenge stems from their exact fit, something about which few builders complain.  Often the seam between dry-fitted parts looks like a panel line, even to the point of matching those surrounding it.  I used Tamiya Extra Thin Cement to glue parts together, but in a couple of instances finding a good place to put it and ensure a secure join without fouling that uniform ‘panel line’ was difficult, since the gluing surfaces are often tiny.  I had to redo things in a couple of places.  Wherever the builder can back up such a seam in an out-of-sight place with Gator’s Grip or a similar flexible glue, is worthwhile.  This includes the fuselage top decking between canopy and cowl; the separate cowl flaps (the circular manifold directly beneath is commendably faithful but leaves hardly any room to secure them); the three-piece engine cowling stuffed full of guns and powerplant, and the cockpit assembly.  These areas require much careful handling in building and detailing.  They are not robust assemblies, especially the cowling and powerplant, and it’s worth shoring up parts from the inside wherever possible. 


"The pattern of the wiring harness, not always quite symmetrical, was largely modeled on Russian photos of a captured Claude, and three other Japanese photos that helped provide some info.  The harness was fashioned from soldering wire, which is great stuff for any kind of bend, holding shape, and accepting paint.  It looks busier than most single-row radials because of the bracing that was bolted out in front of the cylinders, and the air scoops between cylinders at ten and two o’clock.  I’ve noticed similar cowl bracing on British types of the same period, like the Blenheim and Hampden.  Maybe it kept vibration down enough for the pilot to retain his fillings!  The braces ran from the reduction gear housing to the inner edge of the front cowl ring, so had to be installed last.  I stole this photoetched piece from the Wingsy Claude, the only piece of it I’ve used, as the Fine Molds kit omitted it. 


"I prefer to be able to work on the cockpit sidewalls separately before the fuselage halves have been joined.  Building a shell like this to fit into the assembled fuselage from beneath, where the ‘sides’ are just the longerons and ribs, is not as enjoyable.  It’s not a bad as building a ship in a bottle, but unfortunately it might be good practice.  It also limits the chance to easily add certain details if wished.  It’s not a new approach anymore, though, and both kits use this method.  To FM’s credit the stringers and ribs fit flush, though they look heavy for the scale.  Those Russian photos that once appeared online included some flash-lit cockpit shots that, if not comprehensive, are excellent, looking like they were taken at Grumman or Douglas!  (Or maybe they were indeed comprehensive, and I’ve only seen a few).  


"Even without a cockpit enclosure, the interior ends up tough to see easily, except for the seat with its adjustable bracket, and some of the cockpit floor area (synonymous with the upper wing). The instrument panel is well inset under the coaming, and the sidewalls slope out of vision.  For me, hough its basic form carried through to the Zero cockpit, Claude’s office is not as inherently busy or interesting.  The most obvious payoffs to improve the kit here are the beautiful aftermarket Yahu instrument panel, the addition of a seat harness, and an improvement to the clunky-looking molded-on throttle assembly.  The Yahu panel is a light bluish green or turquoise that puzzled me until (and this is just a guess) I noticed the old Maru Mechanic #28 cockpit painting of Claude.  It was this artist’s style to vary colors significantly to express light and angle, and this may have been an extreme example; in any case I was able to repaint it in Mitsubishi Interior Green by dropping some thinned Elmer’s Glue in the recessed dials before re-spraying the panel, which preserved those lovely dials.  I didn’t feel like detailing the area behind the seat, somewhat visible through the oval opening in the bulkhead, so placed a fine mesh screen some distance behind the bulkhead - the one with the oval opening - backing the seat.  It’s a cheap dodge, but I may resort to it again!   Oddly both kits omit all the various equipment and structure behind the seat, unlike the Tamiya newer-tool Zero 22 and 52 kits.


"Take care with fitting the seat and its bracket, as the join is iffy.  Within that oval cockpit opening, misalignment would be distracting.  After test-fitting, hey, I got that one right.  Next day, however, I couldn’t find it anywhere.  I combed the workbench, rifled all the little boxes in the big box . . . then I saw something green on the floor. The coveted assembly. Somebody had stepped on it, and misalignment was the least of its problems.  This moment brought to you by Ambien.  Know your window.


"After a rebuild session for the seat and bracket, main parts fit very nicely and did not require filler except for ‘operator error’ in a couple of places, which happened when I dropped the model from two or three feet while painting it on the porch; epic fail for the coat-hanger jig.    With a new airbrush and a new bottle of Alclad II, things were going so very well until they weren’t, when the airbrush started spitting grainy paint.  I rotated the model to see how much of it was affected, and plop, onto the deck.  Much of it had to be sanded back to primer, and what had to be redone is mostly in Tamiya Bare Aluminum, which I liked a lot – but like the Alclad, whew, the fumes.  (Timothy Leary’s dead.  No no no no . . . he’s outside, spraying Alclad).  It’s hard to know for sure which Claudes might have had an ‘anodized’ finish with a slightly golden or yellowed metal surface.  I had not made up my mind about that decision until these airbrushing difficulties, but afterward decided to leave well enough alone.      


"I think the superb Lifelike Decals used were critical to the model’s final appearance.  They came from Sheet # 2 of their 1/48 Claude trio, and depict W-121, an aircraft from carrier Soryu, a real clothes-horse, date uncertain.  As usual, proprietor Keishiro Nagao’s notes unpack his ‘best guesses’ and the rationale for such, when certain details can’t be absolutely verified, listing all the sources and their page numbers for each aircraft on every sheet.  For those who cannot read Japanese, what a benefit, and a standard to emulate.  The maintenance stencil on the cowling’s left side is not called out; it’s from another Lifelike Claude sheet, and provisional on my part.  The only known photo of W-121 is a profile view of the right side, and I like the look.  As finely printed as they are, these decals are easy to position and tough enough to stay intact when you get things wrong the first two or three times!  They responded well to Micro Set.  I sprayed the tail with Tamiya Flat Red, which was also used for the hinomaru, as I wanted the two to match.  With a semigloss coat, I like the shade.  I toned down the brighter red of the fuselage decal stripe with red-brown pastel powder to bring it a bit closer to this shade (the closeup photo of the razor-sharp Houkokou inscription across the fuselage shows its original brightness). 


"Dead Design masks were used for hinomaru, canopy framing, and wheels.  Those are wonderful products as well, and they fit.  Buy and use them with confidence.  I’ve been underwhelmed by the aftermarket response to the Babs and Claude releases from larger companies like Eduard and Aires, which to my knowledge have so far completely ignored both the Fine Molds and Wingsy Claudes  Modelers of 1/72 and 1/48 Japanese aircraft owe a debt of gratitude to companies like Lifelike, Dead Design, and Rising Decals who provide some alternatives for easier building.  Keishiro, Jan, and Mirek combine passionate research, knowledge, and expertise to bring us some very specialized items. Why should Luftwaffe modelers have all the fun?     

                       
"After decal application and another clearcoat came surface effects with watercolors and pencil, along with some pastels here and there.  Fine Molds’ panel surfaces have slight contrast in their sheen.  Seen in oblique light, on bare plastic it makes a lovely and subtle effect.  I don’t know how one might preserve it throughout the painting process, as doing so would certainly enhance a natural metal or anodized finish; I couldn’t.  The panel line detail is not too heavy-handed, and riveting, where present, is quite nice, but FM is mean-spirited with it, as if they started but decided against it – you just get a few in certain spots, the most concentrated in the bottom center wing.  The Wingsy parts, however, like their Sonia, are quite evenly and finely riveted across all surfaces, with finer panel lines than FM as well.  It made me wonder which kit I should have started! 


"I thought I would try to add rivets in a few places with a Staedtler mechanical pencil, sharpening it during the process by rolling its point on a pad.  “A few places” got away from me after I decided to emphasize wear at the wing roots and couldn’t fade it back as planned.  Easier imagined than executed.  After I enlarged the canvas for it, the problem was consistency: it would look so nice after a certain evening’s work . . . until for some mystical reason I couldn’t do it neatly the next.  It’s forgiving, however, and those little Tamiya cotton swabs, just damp, will remove it easily.  It must be sealed at some point with an overcoat of course to withstand handling.


"Most importantly, I finished it before I dropped it again – that’s the key.  And as often as I was disappointed with something along the way I like the result, which came from reminding myself that if I could only get it in the display case, those things soon wouldn’t matter much.  And they didn’t.  Thanks to Nick for the chance to share it here, which was also a spur to getting it done.  The model is dedicated to a matchless friend for four decades, Mike Quan, who passed away earlier this year.  I miss you already, Mike."    

Mark Smith
                  
The carrier Soryu carried 18 Type 96 Kansen in two Buntai (divisions) of nine aircraft each, the first commanded by Lt  Tamotsu Yokoyama (W-101) and the second by Lt Muchifumo Nango (who from March to July 1938 was also acting Soryu Hikotai leader).  From April 1938 one Soryu Buntai was detached to operate from land bases in China and in July 1938 became the fighter cadre for 15 Ku. The regular pilot of W-121 is unconfirmed (but may have been Lt Kiyoyo Hanamoto who was the 2nd Buntai leader from December 1939 to October 1940), although other aircraft of the unit were flown by such notables as Petty Officers Matsuo Hagiri (W-102) and Hideo Oishi (W-103). The 'W' tail code was carried from December 1938 to November 1940 and the donation ceremony for Houkoku-307 was held on 7 August 1939 at Haneda, Japan. In September 1940 after a period of fleet exercises Soryu returned to blockade operations off the south coast of China, cruising between Hainan Island and Amoy (now Xiamen), a strategic port in Fukien (now Fujian) province opposite the Taiwan Strait.  

With special thanks to Mark for sharing these images of his superb 96 Kansen and the build report.   

Image credits: All photographs © 2020 Mark Smith

      
     

Monday, 4 May 2020

Francesco Borraccino's B5N2 'Kate' in 1/72


Francesco Borraccino kindly treats us to another of his excellently realised 1/72 models - this time the Nakajima B5N2 'Kate' built from the Airfix kit and representing the 553 Ku option provided.


Francesco reports that this build was not as straightforward as expected, requiring a lot of attention to fit. When attempting to mate the wings and fuselage he discovered a gap and a difference in level that was tricky to eliminate. He also found that the forward fuselage parts for the engine needed sanding and several attempts at dry fitting. 


The most difficulty he experienced was fitting the landing gear which following the intended method of construction resulted in a strange and incorrect alignment, with the fit of the landing cover to the wing not permitting the positive insertion of the struts into their locating holes. In his kit the transparent ventral window part was also deformed.  


On the other hand Francesco found a good level of detail in the cockpit and engine parts, although he added some extra panels and seat belts from Tamiya tape. He also considered the panel lines not as deeply engraved as on previous kits. One strange feature of the kit is the fabric effect on the flaps whereas several modellers have asserted that they were metal covered (the jury is out on that Ed.) On the extended flaps the inner starboard part is curiously molded flat so Francesco carved it to match the others.  On completing the build with its ups and downs he was pleased with the result.   


Francesco wanted to depict an aircraft with worn paintwork whilst realising this was something of a cliché for Japanese aircraft models. He began with an overall coat of Tamiya grey primer followed by a coat of Tamiya AS-12 bare metal. The reddish brown primer was replicated with a mixture of XF-7 Flat Red with Gunze H-463 Red Brown and H-406 Chocolate Brown. For the wear and chipping effects Francesco used AK Interactive Worn Effects Fluid and salt grain.     


For the upper surface dark green he used Tamiya XF-11 to represent D1 Deep Green Black and thought it matched better than older examples used, wondering whether Tamiya have modified the formula. The under surfaces were painted with AK Real Colors RC303 J3 SP with a few drops of RC334 Dry Grass Color added to it. Francesco used the kit decals, printed by Cartograf, but encountered issues with the large wing hinomaru using MIcrosol as a result of the large gap between the ailerons and wing trailing edge. In the end he discarded the decals and painted on the wing hinomaru using a mixture XF-7 Red and H-463 Red Brown to match the printed colour of the decal sheet.  He used the kit's fuselage decals because his circle cutter could not create their small size. The propeller and spinner were painted with a ix of H-406 Chocolate Brown and H-462 Schwarzbraun. The model was completed with further weathering achieved with oils, pigments, pastels and a graphite pencil.   


553 Ku were based at the Imaizaki airfield, part of the Kataoka Naval Base on Shumshu in the Kuriles Islands from April 1944 with a mixture of aircraft including the B5N2 and B6N2 Tenzan 'Jill'. In October 1944 the unit was transferred to the Philippines but a remnant left behind was activated as Hokuto Ku to continue ASW missions using four B5N2 and one B6N2. On 10 August 1945 the four Kates bombed Lopatka Point on the tip of the Kamchatka Peninsula. When Soviet aircraft bombed Shumshu two days after the 15 August ceasefire, the Kates sortied to attack a Soviet convoy at Lopatka Point in retaliation.

With special thanks to Francesco for sharing these images of his model and his build report. 

Image credit: All photographs © 2020 Francesco Borraccino

Monday, 27 April 2020

Platz 1/144 scale Nakajima Hayabusa Ki-43-1 'Oscar'


The recent Platz kit of the Nakajima Ki-43-I in 1/144 scale provides two identical sprues to make up two models together with a decal sheet offering four markings options. The kit bears comparison with and should complement the earlier LS kit of the Ki-43-II to the same scale. The LS kit was released in 1976 as a double kit with the Ki-84 Hayate but was most recently available from Arii under the affiliated Micro Ace label. However, examining the two kits together it appears that either the Platz kit fuselage is under scale or the LS kit fuselage is over scale as there is a significant difference between them, especially in the size of the fin and rudder. The dimensions have not been checked against published figures to determine which one is more accurate to scale.  

The note for the wing advises care in cutting off the thick sprue tags as shown

The Platz kit is finely molded in grey plastic and consists of 29 parts including a one piece cockpit canopy in transparent plastic. The parts include cockpit detail absent from the LS kit, consisting of a floor with integrally molded seat, a separate control stick and an instrument panel. The seat is unconvincing even for this scale as the seat back bears little resemblance to the real thing, but the size of the cockpit aperture probably negates that concern. The cockpit colour is called out as metallic blue-green - aotake - with Mr Color 57 or Model Master 4662 suggested. The engine and a firewall with exhausts are separate parts whereas in the simpler 12 part LS/Arii kit the exhausts were molded integrally with the fuselage halves and the cowling and engine were molded as a single piece. The optical gun sight is molded integrally and very neatly with the port fuselage half. The wings of both kits are single piece moldings with integral pitot tubes. In the Platz kit alternative parts are included for an extended undercarriage with separate legs and wheels or a retracted undercarriage with integral one part wheels and covers. The kit also includes under wing racks and drop tanks, the latter each in two parts. The spinner and prop is a single piece, and there is a separate antenna mast, not included in the LS/Arii kit. In both kits the props are designed to spin freely after assembly. 


A highlight of the kit is the decal sheet featuring markings for two camouflaged and two natural metal finish aircraft and sharply printed by Cartograf. The two camouflaged options are for 64th Hiko-Sentai commander Tateo Kato's well-known white-striped machine and a 3rd Chutai, 50th Hiko-Sentai example flown by Sgt Satoru Anabuki. The two natural metal options are for an 18th Hiko-Sentai example in 1944 with white Homeland Defence 'bandages', included on the decal sheet, and a 59th Hiko-Sentai aircraft at Hankow, China in 1941 with a large red lightning flash on the fuselage. The sheet includes two anti-glare panels. All four schemes are shown in four-view colour on the instruction sheet and in profile on the reverse of the attractive box with profile-style artwork by Yukio Furutachi which also features photographs of the assembled and painted models on one side. 


The LS/Arii kit only contains basic decals for a 3rd Chutai, 64th Hiko-Sentai aircraft. Painting instructions are limited to a suggestion to refer to the box art (shown above) which depicts an Oscar in brown 'giraffe' style mottle over grey or natural metal with a yellow fuselage band and white senchi hiyoshiki not included on the decal sheet. This unusual scheme appears to originate from Richard Ward profile E4 in the 1970 Aircam Aviation monograph No.13 'Nakajima Ki.33 Hayabusa I-III in Japanese Army Air Force, RTAF, CAF and IPSF Service' (shown below) perhaps from a tonal interpretation of a photograph in the book or from an earlier Japanese pictorial source?  Originally molded by LS in dark green plastic the Arii Micro Ace release is molded in white plastic. The under cowling oil cooler is molded integrally with the wing and the panel detail is finely engraved.


In the 1972 Revell Japan also released a 1/144 scale Ki-43-II kit as H-1005. This kit was released in the UK a couple of years later in the third issue box shown below. The kit was molded in silver plastic on a single sprue frame and included one-piece droptanks and racks as well as a two-piece black plastic stand and small tube of glue. Although the box art depicted a 64th Sentai Hombu aircraft the decal sheet provided only six hinomaru. The painting instructions suggested dark green upper surfaces over light green under surfaces. The antecedence of this kit, if any, is unknown and the molding is different to the LS kit with a cylindrical cowling with integral exhaust outlets but without intake or gun muzzle detail. The under cowling oil cooler is a separate part and panel detail consists of fine raised lines.     


Frederick Boucher of the AeroScale website has since published a full build review of the Platz kit here.

Image credit:- Platz Ki-43-I images © 2020 Platz; Arii-Micro Ace Ki-43-II images © Arii-Micro Ace; Profile E4 © 1970 Richard Ward & Osprey Publications Ltd; Revell H-1005 box art © 1970s Revell (GB) Ltd